Insurance & Risk Management

3

mins read

How to Plan a Church Toy Drive | Collection, Storage, and Giveaway Day

Planning a Christmas toy drive at your church? See what to think through when collecting, storing, and giving out gifts, and how to care for the families you serve.

Share via:

Christmas Toy Drives at Your Church: Planning the Collection, the Storage, and the Giveaway

The box goes out in the lobby the Sunday after Thanksgiving. By the second week of December it has overflowed twice, someone has dropped off a bicycle, and the youth room is stacked to the windowsills with board games and stuffed animals.

A toy drive is one of the simplest ways a church shows up for its neighbors at Christmas. It is also a small logistics operation, run by volunteers in a building that is already at its busiest. A little planning before the first announcement keeps the attention where it belongs: on the families who will receive the gifts.


Decide what you are collecting before you ask

Many drives run into trouble because the invitation is too open. “Bring a toy” will bring everything from brand-new building sets to a well-loved doll missing an arm. Settle the basics first: new items only or gently used ones too, which age groups you are collecting for, whether gift cards or cash are welcome, and the last day to give.

It helps to say what you cannot accept as well, such as used stuffed animals, toys with missing pieces, and toy weapons. Older and secondhand toys may also have been recalled, which is one reason many drives stay with new, unopened items. If you do take used toys, the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission publishes recall notices you can use to check them.

Put the guidelines in the bulletin and on the box itself.


A short list to settle before you announce the drive

  • Name one person who owns the drive from first box to last gift

  • Choose a storage room that locks and is not needed for other ministries in December

  • Decide how families will be identified, and who is allowed to see that information

  • Set the giveaway date, time, and place, then plan backward from it

  • If another organization is involved, agree on who is responsible for what

  • Tell whoever manages the church’s insurance that the drive is happening


Where will it all go?

Donations arrive slowly, then all at once. Pick a space that locks, stays dry, and keeps boxes clear of exits, heaters, and electrical panels.

Keep a simple log by age group so you can see gaps while there is still time to ask for what is missing. Track gift cards and cash separately, and handle them the way you would any other contribution: counted by two unrelated people, recorded, and locked away. 1225 United’s guide to protecting giving and accountability has more. If a donor asks for a receipt, send them to the church office instead of writing one at the collection table.


Caring for the families who receive

This is the part people remember most. Sign-up forms often collect children’s names and ages, home addresses, and details about a family’s circumstances. Ask only for what you need, limit who can see it, keep it out of group emails and shared spreadsheets, and decide ahead of time when the list will be destroyed.

Then picture the day from a parent’s side. Some churches set up the room like a small shop, so parents can choose gifts for their own children instead of being handed a labeled bag. Others arrange quiet pickup times. Whatever you choose, the aim is for a mother or father to leave feeling welcomed.

Photos of volunteers sorting toys tell the story well. Photos of families receiving gifts should be taken or shared only with clear permission, and many churches skip them entirely. If volunteers will be working directly with children, the screening and supervision practices in your church’s abuse prevention policies apply here too.


What does giveaway day ask of your volunteers?

More than most people expect. There is parking to direct, a line that may form outside in the cold, heavy boxes moving from storage to tables, and guests who have never been inside the building. Assign roles in advance: greeters, runners, someone at the door, and someone who knows where the first-aid kit is kept.

Some drives deliver gifts to homes. If yours does, send volunteers in pairs and agree on a simple check-in when they finish. Ask how that driving is treated under the church’s auto coverage and a volunteer’s own policy. 1225 United’s ministry vehicle and travel guide walks through those questions.

Community partnerships, off-site locations, and volunteer drivers can all change how your coverage applies. A short conversation with your insurance advisor before the first box goes out is the easiest way to know.


A season of good news, well planned

When the tables are folded and the storage room is empty again, what stays with people is rarely the number of toys. It is the parent who was greeted by name and the volunteer who found a new way to serve. Good planning is what makes room for those moments.

Before your church makes its first toy drive announcement, email the 1225 United team at support@1225united.com to talk through how deliveries, partner organizations, and giveaway day fit with your church’s coverage.


Frequently Asked Questions


Should we accept used toys?

That is your church’s call. If you accept used toys, set clear standards and check them before they go out.

What should we do with gifts left over after the giveaway?

Decide before the drive begins. Some churches pass extras to a local partner, and others hold them for families who come forward late. Tell donors the plan so nobody is surprised.

Can we post photos from the giveaway?

Photos of volunteers and donated items are usually fine. For the families receiving gifts, ask first, and leave children out unless a parent has clearly agreed.

Does our church’s insurance cover a toy drive?

It may, depending on your policy and how the drive is run. Deliveries, off-site events, and outside partners are good details to raise with your insurance advisor ahead of time.

More blogs

Brand logo

1225 United brings together decades of practical experience and a broad network of resources—supporting ministries through insurance, operational help, and real partnership.

We care about your data in our privacy policy.

Professional liability insurance included with your 1225 United membership is provided through licensed insurance agencies and underwritten by admitted or authorized insurers. 1225 United is not an insurance company and does not sell, underwrite, or issue insurance policies. Coverage is subject to the terms, conditions, and exclusions of the applicable policy.

1225 United, all rights reserved, 2025

Connect with us:

Brand logo

1225 United brings together decades of practical experience and a broad network of resources—supporting ministries through insurance, operational help, and real partnership.

We care about your data in our privacy policy.

Professional liability insurance included with your 1225 United membership is provided through licensed insurance agencies and underwritten by admitted or authorized insurers. 1225 United is not an insurance company and does not sell, underwrite, or issue insurance policies. Coverage is subject to the terms, conditions, and exclusions of the applicable policy.

1225 United, all rights reserved, 2025

Connect with us:

Brand logo

1225 United brings together decades of practical experience and a broad network of resources—supporting ministries through insurance, operational help, and real partnership.

We care about your data in our privacy policy.

Professional liability insurance included with your 1225 United membership is provided through licensed insurance agencies and underwritten by admitted or authorized insurers. 1225 United is not an insurance company and does not sell, underwrite, or issue insurance policies. Coverage is subject to the terms, conditions, and exclusions of the applicable policy.

1225 United, all rights reserved, 2025

Connect with us:

Church Mutual Insurance Company, S.I. (a stock insurer) | P.O. Box 357 | 3000 Schuster Lane | Merrill, WI 54452-0357 | Telephone (800) 554-2642 or (715) 536-5577
© 2026 Church Mutual Insurance Company, S.I. All rights reserved. Protecting the Greater Good is a registered trademark of Church Mutual Insurance Company, S.I¹ Church Mutual is a stock insurer whose policyholders are members of the parent mutual holding company formed on 1/1/20. S.I. = a stock insurer.

Brand logo

1225 United brings together decades of practical experience and a broad network of resources—supporting ministries through insurance, operational help, and real partnership.

We care about your data in our privacy policy.

Professional liability insurance included with your 1225 United membership is provided through licensed insurance agencies and underwritten by admitted or authorized insurers. 1225 United is not an insurance company and does not sell, underwrite, or issue insurance policies. Coverage is subject to the terms, conditions, and exclusions of the applicable policy.

1225 United, all rights reserved, 2025

Connect with us: